Sean's Pick - score and comments:  

Ok Ok I have selected the better shot out of the mix all
the same and consider it to be your shot

“Infinity and Beyond” as I toyed with the full moon this
month too and found the difficulty in getting a composure
that worked sorted with a reasonable exposure. Although
not spot on – with some blurring and the black corner?
with your copyright logo looking adrift within. Perhaps it
could have improved with some more work justifying,
reducing font etc All the same on topic the best.

Other photos in order of merit:

  • Kangaroo Point: is probably the next in line but
    has a stack of juxtaposed happenings in it for my
    liking. Lens flare, bridge, handrail – logo – it all
    feels over worked.

  • Culture mix: There maybe some method to this
    arrangement but I am again a little lost in
    translation. I am sure there was a shot in this but I
    am not sure if this one is it.

  • Bust: Off topic technically but quite pleasing to
    look at – reminds me of Easter Island

No Further Questions.
Marty's Submissions
Sean's Submissions
February 2011
Topic:
"Silhouette"set
by Sean
This work is by Sean Reason. It is licenced under a Creative Commons Licence
"Polly"
"KangarooPoint"
Martin's photo notes:

Braaaaaz - my lot here...... As per
usual, I am first to submit.

Had some real dilemmas with this
topic. It seemed so unnatural for me
to seek out silhouette. So I decided
to go for the very unsubtle type
images.

Some notes:

  • Bust - Heavy curves, cropped
  • Culture Mix - Curves, cropped
  • Infinity and beyond - cropped,
    desaturated, contrast
  • Kangaroo Point - HDR -
    cropped, curves, desaturated


My website is live as of Monday.....
Check it out http://www.in-site.com.
au. Can I link to your site Braaaaz?

Love to the gang.
"Cola"
"Flyaway"
Relevance to Topic
9
Composition
8
Use of Light
9
Wow Factor
7.5
I wish I took this!!!  
8
Variety
6
Sean's photo notes

Gday mate, well I received  
your disgruntled call and all –
sorry for dragging the chain..

It has been due to some
computer issues that now
appear to be resolved – also
have been processing a stack
of juicy Melbourne HDRs I will
send through next email!!

Ridey”O” here is my lot at last

  • Dukes, actually made
    this diorama setting out
    of one beer box the
    other day whilst
    watching a movie at
    home. Levels,
    Brightness, contrast
    adjustments

  • Flyaway – desat,
    contrast – levels

  • Polly, Cropped, desat,
    contrast

  • Victory, desat, filter
    effect

  • Rockit, Levels,
    Brightness, contrast
    adjustments

  • Cola, Levels,
    Brightness, contrast
    adjustments
NEXT MONTH: Technology- Set by Martin
"Rockit"
Overall with weighting 7.60 / 10
"Culture Mix"
"Victory"
Martin's Pick - score and comments:  "Dukes"


Nice job this month and a half mate!!

Cut and dried this period -  
Dukes takes the gong.
I keep looking through it, around it, behind it, waiting
for something else to happen.... It is intriguing
indeed. I would like to see the other shots that you
binned in order to get this one.

Other photos in order of merit
  • Flyaway  - It's no show stopper, but the mix of
    movement and the busy frame appeals to me.

  • Cola -  Terrific colour and shapes.... But is it
    true silhouette?? Would print nicely.

  • Victory - Hmmmm, not sure of this one. What
    was the applied filter?? Is that your tripod??
    Why are you going away?? Too many
    questions for mine.

  • Polly - Nice and sharp around the beak, but I
    can't get a connection to this shot at all. What
    was cropped away? I am wondering if you cut
    away some clutter, if so maybe put it back..... I
    just dunno
.
  • Rockit - It's tecnically not bad.... But it is
    aesthetically yuck. Is that the Channel 10
    building?

No Further Questions.
"Bust"
"Infinity and Beyond"
"Dukes"
Relevance to Topic
9.5
Composition
8
Use of Light
9
Wow Factor
8.5
I wish I took this!!!  
8.5
Variety
7.5
Overall with weighting 8.20 / 10
Copyright Sean Reason 2011